Overflow Pool vs Skimmer Pool: How They Differ and Which Is Better
Skimmer pools and overflow pools take water off the surface in different ways, and the difference shows in water quality and in day-to-day upkeep. Lorraine explains why overflow is the better system, drawing on PWTAG and Sport England, and what each type needs to keep working well.
A villa pool takes water off the surface in one of two ways. With skimmers, the water sits a little below the edge and goes out through openings in the wall. With overflow, it spills over the edge into a channel that runs right round the pool. People who look up overflow pool vs skimmer are usually trying to understand the pool they own, or planning a refurbishment.
Everything we quote below was written for public pools. We use its figures as a guide to good practice. A private villa doesn't have to follow them, and the exact numbers may not suit your pool, but the thinking behind them still holds.
What is the difference between a skimmer and an overflow pool?
In a skimmer pool, the water sits below the edge and leaves through a few openings in the wall. In an overflow pool, it sits level with the surround and spills all the time into a channel that feeds a balance tank. Most contamination is at the surface. Overflow takes more of the circulation from there.
How a skimmer pool works
A skimmer is an opening in the top of the pool wall, with a basket behind it. Your pump pulls surface water in through it, along with leaves, insects and anything else that floats, and sends it on to the filter. Just inside the mouth there is a small flap called a weir. It floats with the water, so the skimmer keeps drawing from the very top.
Most skimmer pools have more than one, set at intervals along the walls. The rest of the water usually leaves through a drain in the floor. Both streams meet before the filter, and the cleaned water comes back in through the return jets.
What is an overflow pool?
On an overflow pool, the water sits level with the surround and spills over the edge into a channel. In technical guidance you will often see it called a deck-level pool.
The water overflows all the time into a continuous channel set into the surround. That channel can run along the pool edge itself, or sit back behind a tiled margin of about 30 cm. Both layouts appear in Sport England's swimming pool design guidance from May 2013.
There is usually a grill over the channel. Grills are a subject of their own, and we cover them on our page on overflow pool grills.
From the channel, the water runs to a balance tank, then through treatment and back into the pool. The tank keeps your pool at the optimum level for taking water off the surface, under all operating conditions. That is how the Pool Water Treatment Advisory Group (PWTAG) describes its job, in a technical note on balance tank design for deck-level pools, from January 2016.
Which is better, a skimmer or an overflow pool?
The overflow pool is the better system, because it takes more of the circulation from the surface. It comes down to where the dirt is. Most organic pollution and contamination sits at or near the surface, however well the circulation mixes the water. PWTAG makes this point in its Code of Practice on the management and treatment of swimming pool water (July 2021, last updated July 2025).
That Code carries real weight. The UK Health and Safety Executive treats it as the standard a well-managed pool should reach, according to PWTAG. For a really healthy pool, the Code recommends taking 80 to 100% of the circulation from the surface. Going over 80% takes a deck-level pool with a balance tank.
A skimmer pool has no channel and no balance tank. Read that way, the Code leaves it at the bottom of the range at best. PWTAG doesn't give a separate figure for skimmer pools, so this is our own reading. It still tells you which design can take more from the top.
Sport England leans the same way, though its comparison isn't quite like for like. It sets deck-level pools against public pools where the water sits below the edge with a scum channel, which is a little different from a skimmer pool. Bringing the water up level with the surround draws pollutants off the surface more efficiently, it found, and swimmers get less turbulence. For learner pools, there is general agreement that deck-level is preferable.
Skimmer pools do win on one thing. There are fewer parts, with no channel round the edge and no balance tank to keep clean. If you'd rather have less to look after, that's worth something.
What upkeep does an overflow pool need?
On an overflow pool, most of your upkeep goes into the channel and the balance tank. PWTAG's guide to typical pool problems, an undated page based on its book Swimming Pool Water, says that a build-up of organic material in overflow channels and balance tanks can contribute to a strong chlorinous smell and irritated eyes. Cleaning them, it adds, should be part of periodic maintenance where practical.
According to the same page, slimy deposits on pool walls and overflow grills come from bacterial growth and biofilm. The bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa also settles easily in deck-level transfer channels and balance tanks, and the Code of Practice names both. Anything that gets into the channel passes through the balance tank on its way to the pump and the pool filtration system. A clean channel protects everything downstream of it.
Variable speed pumps add one more thing to watch. If you turn the pump down at night, the share of water taken from the surface should never drop with it. PWTAG says this matters even more on a deck-level pool, in its technical note on circulation pumps and variable speed drives, from July 2020. Water still has to keep moving over the edge and into the channel on a slow setting, and skimmers need the same steady draw.
Keep an eye on how often the balance tank needs topping up. If it's more often than it used to be, or water seems to be getting out of the channel, a leak is one possible cause.
We are the only company in Portugal with electronic leak detection equipment, and our pool leak detection service works without draining the pool. We locate the leak and tell you exactly where it is. The repair itself is not work we carry out.
What upkeep does a skimmer pool need?
With skimmers, almost everything comes down to the water level. A skimmer can only skim while the water is within its opening. Let the level drop below it and the surface stops being cleaned. The pump can also start pulling in air.
That level is harder to hold when nobody is at the villa. If you spend months away, a steady level keeps your skimmers working, and automatic water level control is one way to keep it there.
The baskets behind the openings need emptying too. A basket packed with leaves holds back the water your pump is trying to draw. It is a quick job, and a much simpler one than cleaning a channel and a balance tank.
Entrapment and suction safety
Suction is worth a thought whichever type of pool you have. In a spa, the deck-level overflow channel, the skimmers and the main drains all count as suction fittings when it comes to entrapment risk. PWTAG treats them that way in its technical note on suction entrapment in spa pools, from April 2023. One way to cut the risk, it suggests, is to take all the water out through the deck-level channel and have no outlets in the pool tank.
The Code of Practice recommends no gaps over 8 mm, so fingers and toes can't get caught. That figure was written for outlet and inlet covers. We think it is a sensible reference for any grill that bathers can touch.
Can you switch from skimmers to overflow when you refurbish?
Sometimes. Switching from skimmers to overflow is construction work on the pool, though, and whether it is possible or worthwhile depends on how the pool was built. It means building a channel around the edge and a balance tank, neither of which a skimmer pool has. In many cases it makes more sense to ask whether your current system is working as it should.
A pool refurbishment is often the moment to get the existing system working as it should. On an overflow pool that can include the channel and its grills, and on a skimmer pool the skimmers and the water level they depend on. We have supplied and installed pool equipment across the central Algarve since 2008, and you can contact us to arrange a visit if you would like us to look at your pool.